Skip to main content

The best inns in Fish Creek

Check out our selection of great inns in Fish Creek

Filter by:

Review score

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
Harbor Guest House, hotel in Fish Creek

Located in Fish Creek, within a 7-minute walk of Fish Creek Beach and 14 miles of Cana Island Lighthouse, Harbor Guest House has accommodations with a terrace and free WiFi throughout the property as...

Location, and great view
Scored 9.0
9.0
Rated wonderful
Wonderful
33 reviews
Eagle Harbor Inn, hotel in Ephraim

Located in Ephraim, this inn has an indoor current pool, fitness center, and a sauna. Ephraim Beach is only 0.6 mi away. Free WiFi access is available.

Really nice room, pool was close by and since it’s not the busy season, we had it to ourselves and enjoyed our family time.
Scored 8.9
8.9
Rated excellent
Excellent
198 reviews
Beachfront Inn, hotel in Baileys Harbor

Located in Baileys Harbor, 6.6 miles from Cana Island Lighthouse, Beachfront Inn has accommodations with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, a garden and a private beach area.

The muffins were so good - the coffee was excellent too. The view on the water and setting on the water was wonderful too.
Scored 9.0
9.0
Rated wonderful
Wonderful
156 reviews
Sister Bay Inn, hotel in Sister Bay

Located in Sister Bay, a 15-minute walk from Sister Bay Beach, Sister Bay Inn provides accommodations with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, a fitness center and a garden.

They kept the hot tub open. Beautiful view you can walk to town or take the free shuttle. Fire pit. Quiet
Scored 9.0
9.0
Rated wonderful
Wonderful
267 reviews
Coachlite Inn, hotel in Sister Bay

Coachlite Inn is located in Sister Bay, within a 17-minute walk of Sister Bay Beach and 11 miles of Cana Island Lighthouse.

GOOD LOCATION , didnot partake of the breakfest
Scored 8.4
8.4
Rated very good
Very Good
211 reviews
All inns in Fish Creek
Looking for an inn?
Perfect for rustic breaks in the countryside, an Inn is a small property with basic hotel services and typically traditional decor. Inns are fully licensed and have a bar providing food and drinks in the evening – distinguishing them from country or guest houses.

Inns That Guests Love in Fish Creek

See all
  • Scored 9.3
    9.3
    Rated wonderful
    Wonderful
     · 249 reviews
    The Front Desk Receptionist was the Best! Extremely knowledgeable and helpful. She made a Dinner Reservation for us pre my request.
    Kman
    Young couple
  • Avg. price/night: $107.83
    Scored 9.1
    9.1
    Rated wonderful
    Wonderful
     · 244 reviews
    Did not have breakfast. The location was great for close distance to White Gull Inn and Bayside Tavern. Not far from Al Johnson’s in Sister Bay either!
    L
    Lori
    Solo traveler
  • Scored 8.4
    8.4
    Rated very good
    Very Good
     · 447 reviews
    Very comfortable bed. Hot water and great pressure in shower. Front desk staff very helpful and informative about area attractions. Great location right off Hwy 42. English Inn restaurant next door for delicious spinach salad and prime rib.
    Carol
    Solo traveler
  • Scored 9.3
    9.3
    Rated wonderful
    Wonderful
     · 249 reviews
    The Main Street Motel may be the best value lodging option in Fish Creek. It is in a quiet location on the west end of Fish Creek. It is close to some good restaurants like the White Gull Inn and Barringer's, but requires a manageable walk to others such as Julie's Park Cafe for breakfast. The staff is very welcoming and ready with travel and dining tips.
    Kurt
    Young couple
  • Avg. price/night: $101.02
    Scored 8.7
    8.7
    Rated excellent
    Excellent
     · 602 reviews
    The hallways had a gross musty smell, luckily the room did not. The rooms are in need of an update but were adequate. The most disappointing part was that the pool closed at 9pm and since most things in town closed at 5, it would have been nice to get to enjoy the pool once we got back from dinner.
    Susan
    Family with young children
  • Scored 8.3
    8.3
    Rated very good
    Very Good
     · 142 reviews
    This Inn was wonderful! Check in was easy. Room was so quaint and comfortable! The Inn was within walking distance to town shops and restaurants!
    Beth
    Young couple
  • Scored 8.6
    8.6
    Rated excellent
    Excellent
     · 137 reviews
    The location of Fish Creek Inn is beautiful. It sits across from a water view.
    Jeff
    Young couple