Skip to main content

The best guest houses in Fire Island

Check out our pick of great guest houses on

Filter by:


Review score

Wonderful: 9+ Very Good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our top picks Lowest Price First Star rating and price Top reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

The Madison Fire Island Pines

Fire Island Pines

The Madison Fire Island Pines in Fire Island Pines provides adults-only accommodation with an outdoor swimming pool and a terrace. Featuring pool and garden views, this guest house also includes free WiFi.

Show more Show less
7.7
Good
4 reviews