Skip to main content

Search hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Enter your dates to see the latest prices and deals for Shelter Island Heights hotels

Filter by:

Star Rating

Review score

Shelter Island Heights – 2 hotels and places to stay

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island, hotel in Shelter Island Heights

Just 1476 feet to the beach, this bed and breakfast is located in Shelter Island Heights. A free breakfast is served each morning.

Breakfast was a continental breakfast, displayed beautifully with all fresh fruit and bread and cereals, yogurts, homemade crepes.
Scored 9.8
9.8
Rated exceptional
Exceptional
46 reviews
Price from
$931.95
1 night, 2 adults
House on Chase Creek, hotel in Shelter Island Heights

Offering garden views, House on Chase Creek in Shelter Island Heights provides accommodations, a garden, and a terrace.

It’s a beautiful area
Scored 8.1
8.1
Rated very good
Very Good
20 reviews
Price from
$106.80
1 night, 2 adults
The Harbor Front Inn, hotel in Shelter Island Heights

Offering a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center, The Harbor Front Inn is centrally located near the shops and restaurants in Greenport. Free WiFi access is available.

Excellent from start to finish!
Scored 8.4
8.4
Rated very good
Very Good
206 reviews
Price from
$152.15
1 night, 2 adults
The Pridwin Hotel, hotel in Shelter Island Heights

The Pridwin is a waterfront resort located on Shelter Island with 33 well-appointed guest rooms and 16 private cottages an all-American restaurant and lively lounge with water views a full service...

The staff was wonderful. The facilities exceeded expectation. Absolutely wonderful.
Scored 9.0
9.0
Rated wonderful
Wonderful
79 reviews
Price from
$405.90
1 night, 2 adults
The Menhaden Hotel, hotel in Shelter Island Heights

Located in Greenport and with Splish Splash reachable within 26 miles, The Menhaden Hotel has concierge services, allergy-free rooms, free bikes, free WiFi throughout the property and a terrace.

The hotel is continently located and spotless. The staff is warm, welcoming, and attentive. They offered the little extras that made our stay perfect!
Scored 9.3
9.3
Rated wonderful
Wonderful
121 reviews
Price from
$262.65
1 night, 2 adults
See all hotels in and around Shelter Island Heights

What Guests Said About Shelter Island Heights:

  • Scored 8.0
    8.0

    We stayed at the House on Chase Creek.

    We stayed at the House on Chase Creek. The location is beautiful, quiet and peaceful. The host, Bill, was friendly, kind and full of recommendations for dining and sights to see on the island. The best thing was just relaxing on the porch swing and enjoying the quiet and stillness. We enjoyed driving and stopping at different locations enjoying the beaches and nature. There is a place in town to rent bicycles to get around. The place we stayed was with in walking distance to town. The restaurants we ate at were, The Chequit, Marie Eiffel Market, Vine Street Cafe, and The Islander.
    Stephen
    United States of America