Skip to main content

Search hotels in Middlebury

Enter your dates to see the latest prices and deals for Middlebury hotels

Filter by:

Star Rating

Review score

Middlebury – 3 hotels and places to stay

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
Essenhaus Inn & Conf. Center, hotel in Middlebury

Located in Middlebury, 13 miles from Midwest Museum of American Art, Essenhaus Inn & Conf. Center has accommodations with a fitness center, free private parking, a shared lounge and a terrace.

Outstanding in every way.
Scored 9.3
9.3
Rated wonderful
Wonderful
878 reviews
Price from
$159
1 night, 2 adults
Hampton Inn & Suites Middlebury, hotel in Middlebury

Located off Highway 20, this hotel is a 2-minute drive from Spring Meadow Farm Golf Club. It features a daily hot breakfast, an indoor pool and rooms with free Wi-Fi.

Excellent, lady that took care did an great job of replenishing all items, and was very friendly
Scored 7.9
7.9
Rated good
Good
299 reviews
Price from
$101
1 night, 2 adults
The Wellington Lake Cottage, hotel in Middlebury

The Wellington Lake Cottage offers accommodations in Middlebury, 22 miles from Midwest Museum of American Art and 24 miles from Swiss Valley Ski and Snowboard Area.

Just perfect, exactly as shown on the pictures
Scored 9.8
9.8
Rated exceptional
Exceptional
8 reviews
Price from
$116
1 night, 2 adults
Blue Gate Garden Inn, hotel in Middlebury

Located in northern Indiana, in the heart of Amish Country, this hotel is 10 minutes’ walk from the Shipshewana Auction & Flea Market.

The Blue Gate is such a charming hotel for its large size. The decor is fun with all its figures, including life-size livestock and a farmer on a tractor! The pizza/ice cream parlor was fun and yummy! The best part was all the spaces for guests to sit and visit, and they did, which was so cool to see people enjoying the hotel instead of just going to and from their rooms. The guests ranged from families with young kids to mature adults. There was something for all to do. Our group consisted of a grandma, mother, and two teen daughters. We all had so much fun together and laughed so much. It was an expectedly great time, and we will be back!!
Scored 9.2
9.2
Rated wonderful
Wonderful
2,518 reviews
Price from
$140
1 night, 2 adults
Farmstead Inn and Conference Center, hotel in Middlebury

Located across the street from the famous Shipshewana Auction & Flea Market, Farmstead Inn and Conference Center is located in the heart of Shipshewana Amish Country and features an indoor pool,...

We appreciated the quiet atmosphere.
Scored 9.1
9.1
Rated wonderful
Wonderful
1,039 reviews
Price from
$142
1 night, 2 adults
Van Buren Hotel, hotel in Middlebury

Located in Shipshewana, 1.6 mi from Shipshewana Flea Market, Van Buren Hotel features accommodations with a fitness center, free private parking and a shared lounge.

Convenient to where I need to go
Scored 8.1
8.1
Rated very good
Very Good
841 reviews
Price from
$149
1 night, 2 adults
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Goshen, hotel in Middlebury

Featuring 3-star accommodations, Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Goshen is located in Goshen, 31 miles from Notre Dame Stadium and 13 miles from Midwest Museum of American Art.

Staff was very friendly! Room was great!
Scored 8.7
8.7
Rated excellent
Excellent
151 reviews
Price from
$121
1 night, 2 adults
Hampton Inn Goshen, hotel in Middlebury

Set in the heart of Indiana's Amish Country and a short drive from local sites, this Goshen, Indiana hotel features a free daily hot breakfast along with in-room flat-screen TVs.

It was a very nice hotel. Great that they provided an early breakfast bag. We left earlier than 6 am.
Scored 8.0
8.0
Rated very good
Very Good
175 reviews
Price from
$86
1 night, 2 adults
Super 8 by Wyndham Shipshewana, hotel in Middlebury

Featuring free Wi-Fi access, this Indiana hotel is located next door to events at the Shipshewana Town Center in the heart of Amish country. A daily grab and go breakfast is served to all guests.

Close to everything
Scored 7.8
7.8
Rated good
Good
618 reviews
Price from
$89
1 night, 2 adults
Quality Inn & Suites, hotel in Middlebury

Right off of U.S. Route 33 in Northern Indiana’s Amish Country, this Quality Inn & Suites location provides quick access to several local attractions, including the National New York Central Railroad...

Friendly staff, clean rooms and comfortable
Scored 6.1
6.1
Rated pleasant
Pleasant
162 reviews
Price from
$67
1 night, 2 adults
See all hotels in and around Middlebury

What Guests Said About Middlebury:

  • Scored 10
    10

    I loved the scenery. Driving from Shipshewana to Middlebury!

    I loved the scenery. Driving from Shipshewana to Middlebury! The Amish farms and getting a small glimpse of their lifestyle. Also the curvy roads, perfect for driving slow, tak8ng in small town scenery....very relaxing and enjoyable! The scenery and trails at the Essenhause hotel were absolutely lovely,
    A
    Anonymous
  • Scored 8.0
    8.0

    Middlebury is a small town in the Amish part of Northern...

    Middlebury is a small town in the Amish part of Northern Indiana. Essenhaus Inn and Conference center is adjacent to a large restaurant and gift shop. There are several very nice gift shops on the same property, as well as a couple of paths that are accessible from the hotel that accommodate pedestrians, bicyclists, and even an Amish horse and buggy ride. One even has a small, covered bridge that some local boys were fishing from. Since we only stayed one night, we did not experience much in the area, but did go over to see Krider's World's Fair Garden, about 5-10 minutes from the hotel, and the grounds were lovely and rustic. The Amish town of Shipshewana is only a few minutes' drive from Middlebury, and it has lots of amenities and shops. There are several hotels, and even a hotel with a dinner theater. The town also has a weekly flea market. If you are looking for a quiet, clean, quaint get-away, the Middlebury area might just be the place for you!
    DaisyRose93
    United States of America
  • Scored 8.0
    8.0

    Very beautiful area, lots of horses and buggys for extra...

    Very beautiful area, lots of horses and buggys for extra ambience Essenhaus property is very, very nice. We visited a bar called Wedgewood Pub and didn't care for that. Way too loud and although the boneless wings were very good, the sauce (garlic parmesan) was terrible.
    Elizabeth
    United States of America
  • Scored 6.0
    6.0

    Legendary Grind-great coffee and treats.

    Legendary Grind-great coffee and treats. Do not stay at the Hampton Inn! Cute town but we didn’t find many shops. We loved the Krider World Fair Garden! Had good food at Rullis but it was very loud!
    Sally
    United States of America
  • Scored 10
    10

    Middlebury is the gateway to northern Indiana's Amish region...

    Middlebury is the gateway to northern Indiana's Amish region, offering modern amenities in a quaint setting. Amish craftsmen and women work in the area's large recreational vehicle industry, yet commute to and from their jobs by horse-drawn buggy or on bicycles. The quiet streets are safe and pleasant to walk, the people are friendly, and the pace is measured.
    Gary
    United States of America
  • Scored 10
    10

    Northridge pizza my burger wAs amazing husband had pizza...

    Northridge pizza my burger wAs amazing husband had pizza grinder homemade bread Husband ate the llama licious ice cream and it was fabulousThe people in town are very sweet and will talk to you and start a conversation with you anytime and pretty much everyone offers to give advice on where to go it’s like you step back in time it’s absolutely wonderful
    Laura
    United States of America

Explore guest reviews of hotels in Middlebury

  • From $178.08 per night
    Scored 9.3
    9.3
    Rated wonderful
    Wonderful
     · 878 reviews
    Breakfast was great. The hotel was clean and the staff was very nice. The shops had a lot to offer. The restaurant was very busy as usual, and the food was good. We also didn't have to wait at all because the front desk staff can make you a reservation. The free cookies and coffee/hot chocolate were a nice little bonus. The grounds are gorgeous and very well maintained. We had a lovely time.
    J
    Jamie
    United States of America
  • From $178.08 per night
    Scored 9.3
    9.3
    Rated wonderful
    Wonderful
     · 878 reviews
    The grounds and landscaping are absolutely beautiful. The decor is fitting to the area. Every area was very clean. The balcony is a wonderful amenity. The breakfast exceeded expectations - gravy and egg casserole were very good & better than you'd find at other hotel breakfasts. Would definitely stay here again!
    Melissa
    United States of America
  • From $178.08 per night
    Scored 9.3
    9.3
    Rated wonderful
    Wonderful
     · 878 reviews
    We LOVED this location. The hotel is clean, quiet, and peaceful. The rooms are tastefully decorated and the common area is fantastic, filled with games to play. The breakfast was generous, and the onsite restaurant is a must for dinner.
    Phil
    United Kingdom
  • From $178.08 per night
    Scored 9.3
    9.3
    Rated wonderful
    Wonderful
     · 878 reviews
    This hotel is EVERYTHING! The breakfast is amazing, the staff was friendly, the pool and game room was our favorite part! The atmosphere was amazing!
    Miranda
    United States of America
  • From $178.08 per night
    Scored 9.3
    9.3
    Rated wonderful
    Wonderful
     · 878 reviews
    This is our go-to hotel when visiting the area. The rooms are always clean and cozy. The breakfast is wonderful, and the pool area is always nice.
    Vanessa
    United States of America