Skip to main content

Search hotels in Bay Shore

Enter your dates to see the latest prices and deals for Bay Shore hotels

Filter by:

Star Rating

Review score

Bay Shore – 1 hotel or place to stay

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex, hotel in Bay Shore

Located in Central Islip, 25 miles from Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex provides accommodations with free WiFi and free private parking.

Cleanliness
Scored 8.5
8.5
Rated very good
Very Good
278 reviews
Price from
$195
1 night, 2 adults
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex, hotel in Bay Shore

Located off Heckscher State Parkway, this Long Island hotel features an indoor pool and free Wi-Fi. Bethpage Ballpark, home of the Long Island Ducks, is a short walk from the hotel.

The location was perfect! The property was clean, friendly staff and a great selection for breakfast.
Scored 8.5
8.5
Rated very good
Very Good
112 reviews
Price from
$220
1 night, 2 adults
Hampton Inn Long Island/Commack, hotel in Bay Shore

Set off the Long Island Expressway and within driving distance of beautiful beaches and other local attractions, this hotel offers modern guestrooms.

It was good, location was good for us
Scored 8.3
8.3
Rated very good
Very Good
257 reviews
Price from
$144
1 night, 2 adults
Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island, an IHG Hotel, hotel in Bay Shore

Off the Long Island Expressway and close to popular local attractions, this Hauppauge, New York hotel features comfortable guestrooms and many free amenities, including a daily hot breakfast.

Rooms clean, staff friendly.
Scored 7.8
7.8
Rated good
Good
409 reviews
Price from
$147
1 night, 2 adults
Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island, hotel in Bay Shore

Offering an indoor pool and an a la carte restaurant, Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island is located in Hauppauge. Free Wi-Fi access is available. The property offers free on-site parking.

Room looks clean. Great costumer service
Scored 5.5
5.5
Rated fair
Average
470 reviews
Price from
$149
1 night, 2 adults
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia, hotel in Bay Shore

Located on Long Island, this Islandia hotel features an indoor pool and free Wi-Fi and a continental breakfast. Long Island MacArthur Airport is 5.7 mi away from the hotel.

Very friendly staff
Scored 7.9
7.9
Rated good
Good
518 reviews
Price from
$119
1 night, 2 adults
Hilton Long Island/Huntington, hotel in Bay Shore

In the Melville business district, in the heart of Long Island, this hotel in Huntington, New York offers on-site recreational activities and dining options.

Location
Scored 7.2
7.2
Rated good
Good
883 reviews
Price from
$161
1 night, 2 adults
Courtyard Long Island MacArthur Airport, hotel in Bay Shore

Located 1 mile from Lake Ronkonkoma, Courtyard Long Island MacArthur Airport offers an indoor swimming pool. Luxurious, marble bathrooms are included with each spacious, air-conditioned guestroom.

Scored 8.3
8.3
Rated very good
Very Good
184 reviews
Price from
$152
1 night, 2 adults
Homewood Suites by Hilton Long Island-Melville, hotel in Bay Shore

Located in Plainview, 0.9 mi from Old Bethpage Village Restoration Park, this hotel offers an indoor pool and a hot tub. Accommodations has flat-screen TVs and well-equipped kitchens.

Clean , good location nice social with food and wine on Wedding
Scored 8.3
8.3
Rated very good
Very Good
189 reviews
Price from
$170
1 night, 2 adults
Best Western Bar Harbour Inn, hotel in Bay Shore

Located in Massapequa Park, within 11 miles of Jones Beach and 11 miles of Nikon Theater, Best Western Bar Harbour Inn has accommodations with free WiFi throughout the property.

Great location
Scored 7.3
7.3
Rated good
Good
511 reviews
Price from
$142
1 night, 2 adults
See all hotels in and around Bay Shore

What Guests Said About Bay Shore:

  • Scored 10
    10

    Wonderful “homey” inn with a friendly staff, great breakfast...

    Wonderful “homey” inn with a friendly staff, great breakfast and comfortable rooms. The location is great and near the marina as well as shops in Bay Shore. We spent most of our days at Robert Moses State Park for a three day beach trip. It is within a 10 minute drive.
    A
    Anonymous
  • Scored 2.0
    2.0

    Nothing to like old run down hotel, during our stay someone...

    Nothing to like old run down hotel, during our stay someone literally opened our room door ar 2:30an and this was attempted twice again. Luckily I had put the the safety latch on door !!! Complain to hotel and staff was done and all appeared dumb founded, no credit provided for a scary situation were our safety was compromised and what hotel has repairs going on after midnight!!!!
    Emma
    United States of America
  • Scored 10
    10

    Charming beach town with friendly people, lots of intriguing...

    Charming beach town with friendly people, lots of intriguing restaurants (Tula Kitchen serves perfect modern comfort foods with a fabulous array of vegetarian and vegan options, plus luscious cocktails and unique, tempting desserts), tons of historic character, and beautiful town beach. Easy drive to Fire Island.
    Janna
    United States of America

Explore guest reviews of hotels in Bay Shore

  • Scored 5.1
    5.1
    Rated fair
    Average
     · 161 reviews
    We wanted a clean quiet room for a Long Island Sunday overnight while visiting friends nearby. It was. We wanted a good night's rest, NOT a pampered experience. I don't know where the bad reviews are from. Our room was just right: clean bathroom, clean bedding with no "crunchy" quilt, clean marble floor. New a/c unit - quiet and cool.
    David
    United States of America
  • Scored 9.7
    9.7
    Rated exceptional
    Exceptional
     · 23 reviews
    The house was beautiful. Our room (the Prospect) was lovely. Our bathroom was so cute and spotless. The innkeepers, Jenn and Liz should win inkeepers of the year. They were the best. We have decided that this is the best b&b experience ever for us. Truly.
    A
    Anonymous
    United States of America
  • Scored 9.7
    9.7
    Rated exceptional
    Exceptional
     · 23 reviews
    Location was good for Bay Shore, half way between the marinas and the town centre so easy to walk around. Number lock system meant we were able to check in easily without bothering anyone. Breakfast was great, nice & fresh.
    AMY
    Greece
  • Scored 9.7
    9.7
    Rated exceptional
    Exceptional
     · 23 reviews
    The house and furnishings are gorgeous. Our bed and room were amazing. Coffee was wonderful! The location is perfect for walking into town or to the marina with many great restaurants nearby.
    Hunter
    United States of America
  • Scored 5.1
    5.1
    Rated fair
    Average
     · 161 reviews
    the location very save area and cute place great for the money nothing fancy but if you want to save money and place to sleep is great
    rafael
    United States of America