Skip to main content

Vacation Rentals for every style

Find the right vacation rental for you in Montauk

The best vacation rentals in Montauk

Check out our selection of great vacation rentals in Montauk

Filter by:

Review score

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
North Harbor Montauk, hotel in Montauk

North Harbor Montauk is located in Montauk, just a 13-minute walk from Gin Beach and 1.7 miles from Navy Road Beach. This property offers access to a balcony, free private parking, and free Wifi.

Great size, very clean
Scored 8.7
8.7
Rated excellent
Excellent
45 reviews
Price from
$425
per night
Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort, hotel in Montauk

Located 1640 feet from Kirk Park Beach, Apartment in Royal Atlantic Beach Resort offers accommodations in Montauk. Guests benefit from balcony. Free WiFi is featured .

Malissa was wonderful. Great communication and very efficient. The location was awesome, the apartment was cozy and comfortable. Having a pool onsite was really nice.
Scored 8.4
8.4
Rated very good
Very Good
40 reviews
Price from
$300
per night
East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast, hotel in Montauk

Located in the historic artists' community of Clearwater Beach East Hampton, NY, this Villa provides access to the private and pristine Clearwater Bay Beach and Marina.

The choices of breakfast was outstanding!! Anything you asked for they had.
Scored 9.7
9.7
Rated exceptional
Exceptional
23 reviews
Price from
$761.50
per night
The Baker House 1650, hotel in Montauk

Offering a spa center and sauna, The Baker House 1650 is located in East Hampton in the New York State Region. Guests can enjoy the on-site bar.

Beautiful old school charm! Delicious food and wonderful staff. Location Location Location
Scored 9.0
9.0
Rated wonderful
Wonderful
36 reviews
Price from
$700
per night
The Huntting Inn, hotel in Montauk

1.4 miles from Egypt Beach in East Hampton, The Huntting Inn offers accommodations with access to wellness packages.

Very warm and friendly people. Nice ambiance even though was low season
Scored 8.4
8.4
Rated very good
Very Good
24 reviews
Price from
$621
per night
Mill House Inn, hotel in Montauk

Providing garden views, Mill House Inn in East Hampton features accommodations, a garden, and a terrace.

Location - I could escape to other places and not spend a minute here beyond sleeping
Scored 8.3
8.3
Rated very good
Very Good
53 reviews
Price from
$550
per night
Townhouses & Captain's Quarters, hotel in Montauk

This Montauk house is located within easy walking distance from the beach and features a private balcony. Guests have access to an outdoor swimming pool and games room.

Great location and deck
Scored 9.0
9.0
Rated wonderful
Wonderful
7 reviews
The Ocean Dunes at Amagansett, hotel in Montauk

Offering a private beach area and barbecue facilities, The Ocean Dunes at Amagansett in Amagansett is close to Indian Wells Beach and Atlantic Avenue Beach.

Location. Walking distance into Amagansett and own private beach access. Nice quiet pool.
Scored 6.1
6.1
Rated pleasant
Pleasant
16 reviews
All vacation rentals in Montauk

Most booked vacation rentals in Montauk this month

Vacation Rentals That Guests Love in Montauk

  • Scored 8.2
    8.2
    Rated very good
    Very Good
     · 203 reviews
    Ocean Surf Resort provided our family with a great overall experience! The resort is directly on the beach and in short walking distance to the main village area. The room was very clean, and the staff was just all around wonderful and helpful. We definitely plan to return next year!
    Frank
    Family with young children
  • Avg. price/night: $192.03
    Scored 8.1
    8.1
    Rated very good
    Very Good
     · 381 reviews
    Room was very clean, large for studio, great views of water, relaxing. Nice pool. Close to Gosman's Dock, Montauk Lighthouse and village.
    M
    Maria
    Family with young children
  • Avg. price/night: $242.31
    Scored 8.7
    8.7
    Rated excellent
    Excellent
     · 1,082 reviews
    This hotel provided us with an outdoor terrace where we enjoyed daily views of the Atlantic Ocean. The hotel's location is also right in the heart of the Village of Montauk. There were many restaurants, bars and stores within walking distance. Also, every destination (MTK Lighthouse, the various NYS Parks, historical landmarks, etc.) was within a short and easy drive.
    Craig
    Young couple
  • Avg. price/night: $150.46
    Scored 7.6
    7.6
    Rated good
    Good
     · 1,050 reviews
    Went to surf cast perfect spot on the beach in the village - priced right
    frank
    Solo traveler
  • Avg. price/night: $172.23
    Scored 7.9
    7.9
    Rated good
    Good
     · 861 reviews
    I appreciated the proximity to the main village and docks
    Reginald
    Young couple
  • Avg. price/night: $373.88
    Scored 8.0
    8.0
    Rated very good
    Very Good
     · 187 reviews
    The Surf Club is in a prime location for beach and Montauk Village. We walked to all restaurants and shops. The pool is centrally located to all units, not too crowded and the online reminders to order chairs and umbrellas for beach is included in price and awesome. They have simple happy hours at the pool certain nights which is also included and nice.
    Karen
    Family with young children
  • Scored 8.5
    8.5
    Rated very good
    Very Good
     · 575 reviews
    Nice staff Clean bedroom Nice and quiet area Options to easily access Montauk old village
    Guillaume
    Family with young children
  • Avg. price/night: $192.03
    Scored 8.1
    8.1
    Rated very good
    Very Good
     · 381 reviews
    Location is amazing, right on the water and close to the village and where I need to go fishing. Room was quaint and cozy but spacious.
    J
    JAMES
    Group
  • Scored 8.2
    8.2
    Rated very good
    Very Good
     · 203 reviews
    The staff were extremely helpful and friendly and were quick to respond to any request. The hotel room and property are kept in pristine condition. The location is wonderful, near the village within walking distance. The beach views were beautiful.
    SUSAN
    Young couple
  • Avg. price/night: $150.46
    Scored 7.6
    7.6
    Rated good
    Good
     · 1,050 reviews
    Close to village, that’s it
    R
    Ralph
    Young couple

Research, refine, and make plans for your whole trip