Skip to main content

B&Bs for every style

Find the right B&B for you in Shelter Island

The best B&Bs in Shelter Island

Check out our pick of great B&Bs in Shelter Island

Filter by:

Review score

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island, hotel in Shelter Island

Just 450 metres to the beach, this bed and breakfast is located in Shelter Island Heights. A free breakfast is served each morning.

Wonderful location and spotlessly clean. Our host provided an excellent breakfast with plenty of gluten free options.
Scored 9.8
9.8
Rated exceptional
Exceptional
45 reviews
Price from
£361.42
1 night, 2 adults
ZEY HOTEL, hotel in Shelter Island

Set in Greenport, within 42 km of Splish Splash, ZEY HOTEL is an accommodation offering garden views. This bed and breakfast offers free private parking and full-day security.

OMG Mia was fantastic from check in to check out. Nothing was too much trouble, she was the perfect host and whatever she is paid - isn’t enough!! She went above and beyond and made us feel so welcome it was exceptional. Room was superb, so many chill out spaces were a brilliant asset to comfortably sit and read our books due to rainy/cloudy weather. The location is like Mia, second to none!! Some reviews suggest it being dated - I think they themselves are the ones who are dated, as the place is designed and styled to be retro, quirky, individual and stylish, it’s a shame this unique property isn’t given the applause it deserves.
Scored 8.7
8.7
Rated fabulous
Fabulous
200 reviews
Price from
£353.94
1 night, 2 adults
House on Chase Creek, hotel in Shelter Island

Set in Shelter Island Heights, House on Chase Creek provides accommodation with air conditioning and access to a garden. This bed and breakfast offers free private parking and a 24-hour front desk.

Location, and view from Room 2, lovely. Quiet.
Scored 8.0
8.0
Rated very good
Very good
21 reviews
Price from
£92.35
1 night, 2 adults
Historic White Blossom House, hotel in Shelter Island

Offering free bike hire and free WiFi access, Historic White Blosson House is a uniquely furnished inn located in Southold. The property features scenic gardens.

Lovely backyard and overall house appearance. Cozy rooms, well organized for being a summer house.
Scored 8.2
8.2
Rated very good
Very good
14 reviews
Price from
£326.12
1 night, 2 adults
The Baker House 1650, hotel in Shelter Island

Offering a spa centre and sauna, The Baker House 1650 is located in East Hampton in the New York State Region. Guests can enjoy the on-site bar.

Beautiful setting with lovely older style decor. Gorgeous gardens with several heated pools and lovely areas in which to relax.
Scored 9.0
9.0
Rated superb
Superb
35 reviews
Price from
£260.17
1 night, 2 adults
The Huntting Inn, hotel in Shelter Island

Offering a bar and garden view, The Huntting Inn is located in East Hampton, 2.2 km from Egypt Beach and 2.5 km from Wiborg Beach.

Staff were super friendly and helpful. Very knowledgeable about the local area. They were very attentive organised a bike for me to borrow.
Scored 8.4
8.4
Rated very good
Very good
24 reviews
Price from
£476.20
1 night, 2 adults
Aria & Mare Hamptons, hotel in Shelter Island

Set in Hampton Bays and only 1.6 km from Meschutt Beach, Aria & Mare Hamptons offers accommodation with sea views, free WiFi and free private parking.

Very nice home and great people! Thanks, we come again! (Beide upstate...😃)
Scored 9.5
9.5
Rated exceptional
Exceptional
147 reviews
Price from
£308.41
1 night, 2 adults
Harpoon House, hotel in Shelter Island

Situated in Southampton, 2.2 km from Gin Beach and 2.5 km from Cryder Beach, Harpoon House features spacious air-conditioned accommodation with a terrace and free WiFi.

Space and comfortable, clean and very comfortable
Scored 8.4
8.4
Rated very good
Very good
27 reviews
Price from
£278.73
1 night, 2 adults
Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast, hotel in Shelter Island

This historic bed and breakfast in Long Island features free Wi-Fi, spa services, and individually decorated rooms equipped with a flat-screen TV.

The B&B is surrounded by a beautiful large garden and is run by a really nice couple, Veda and Wilfred. The rooms are each unique and tastefully furnished. The morning coffee is served up to the room, which we really appreciated. Breakfast was just amazing! Veda always prepared an excellent 3-course breakfast. We really enjoyed the company of the hosts and other guests and missed these morning talks the rest of our trip. It was really fun! Thank you, Veda and Wilfred, for 5 unforgettable days that made our trip to LI so special!
Scored 9.6
9.6
Rated exceptional
Exceptional
14 reviews
The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport, hotel in Shelter Island

This Greenport bed and breakfast is located on the water and offers free Wi-Fi and individually decorated rooms equipped with electric fireplaces. Island’s End Golf & Country Club is 2 miles away.

The owner's homemade bread and baking stuff were very delicious! The best breakfast I ever had in B&B in the States. Location is also good, walking distance from the Town center but very quiet location in front of the sea.
Scored 9.7
9.7
Rated exceptional
Exceptional
26 reviews
All B&Bs in Shelter Island
Looking for a B&B?
For travellers who enjoy beauty in the simple things, a bed and breakfast (B&B) is the perfect place for a getaway. Hosts welcome guests into their homes and provide a private room and complimentary breakfast. Bathrooms may be shared by other guests, and there is often shared space with the host.

B&Bs that guests love in Shelter Island

  • Scored 8.1
    8.1
    Rated very good
    Very good
     · 34 reviews
    It is a very charming hotel in a beautiful natural landscape with dears rabbits squirrels. The beach was cozy and the stuff was extremely nice and friendship. It was the best relaxing few days to close our New York visit. I will never forget this holiday.
    Timea
    Family with young children